I don't know about it being a joke, more of a badly planned publicity campaign that could seriously backfire. People are going to think the band are either a self-important bunch of twats who take themselves too seriously, a bunch of big cry-babies or just plain desperate. None of those options would make me want to spend time or money going to their gigs or buying their products. (Unless Neil has actually set up the whole thing with a fake band to get publicity for aberdeen-music.com, which would be quite clever) Anyway, to have a chance of winning this case the band would have to prove that people breached the rules of the forum and it went unmoderated, although I can't remember any rules saying "You shall not give negative opinions on bands". They'd also have to prove they had lots of gigs before the comments were posted but very little after. The more I think about it, it can't be real, it must be fake. Could a band really be that stupid?