RF Scott

I liked them! Loads of great albums

You realise that Tony Blair was in charge of the UK Government?

How many songs are you wanting to do? Is it for a release or demos???

What's your budget? What would the recordings be for? Where are you based?

I could probably do it for you mate

got the Real Estate and Ducktails LPs last night!

They're a lot more well known than The Twilight Sad...

I'm talking about bands like Maximo Park! Basically, all lists are subjective, obviously, and there's going to be a lot of debate about a list which simply has the title, 'best'.

I wanted to go to this but was watching Real Estate in Glasgow!

Well, as you say, there are no real ground rules, so the fact that they only released one album (so have Glasvegas...) and that it wasn't commercially successful, shouldn't really matter? I'd say the influence that the band have had on other Scottish/UK/Worldwide bands that have gone on to become pretty big makes them more than worthy of inclusion!

listen to it more that's what everyone says when they first hear them!

That's a pointless, safe list that might as well be called 'The best Scottish bands of the Nineties', since the vast majority of those in the list released their best work then... I know they're still making music, but by that definition you could call The Who the best British band of the Noughties!!! I'd have put Life Without Buildings in there for a start, incredibly influential (and my favourite band!). And, though I don't like them personally, Biffy Clyro would have been a good shout, based on how influential to a lot of people there are/their commercial success.

I don't think raising money for something like this has any place for creative standards! It's simply a case of getting as much money on the go as possible.

Yeah mate, all the Haitians are using banditry to rob the supply chains of aid. Also, I'd look to most of the Western powers for major factors in Haiti's poverty...

Unless you are a covers band doing it for the money, why the heck would you play two nights in a row, different venues, playing four hour sets, potentially?!

What's it for, out of interest? The old Boss analogue delay pedal is brilliant, if you can find it.

Big Star - Keep An Eye On The Sky boxset Spectrals 7" Mount Eerie - Wind's Poem 2 x LP and preordered the new Field Music album.

BUMP, sorry... Cheaper advance tickets at WeGotTickets - Your Online Box Office ... Also, QUESTION. Would there be demand for physical tickets from One Up for this? I'm aware some people don't like buying online, but also dont' want to waste a bunch of paper!

Against The Day is crap, but apart from that he's completely amazing. I wrote my dissertation on him last year.

It's also worth pointing out that Cadbury is already owned by Hersheys in the States. Also, for those getting pissy about factories potentially closing down, Cadbury have been moving production to other countries in Europe for years now!!!

which is owned by Cadbury :s...

They're doing a session on BBC 6 Music right now

This is a weird place to air this gripe! Especially with the vague 'you know who I'm talking about' !! Maybe just email the person(s) in question?!! Anyway, I think it's fair to say that a lot of people go to clubs/pubs/gigs/cinema when they're underage. Unless you ID absolutely everyone, then there's always going to be people slipping through. As you yourself said, you 'knew' because you run an underage rock night. Not everyone runs an underage rock night as far as I know, so it wouldn't have been as obvious!

Didn't you post a photo of you and your dog recently?

Where did it say that I was upset, mate? Your post just reeked of pretension, and internet or 'IRL', there's a lot to be said for not being cold and pricky when talking about someone who has just died.