Then why tear them apart so much? Surely with a new band you should look at the positives, with the understanding that technical issues will improve with practice and experience. Aberdeen does have a lack of good bands at the minute, Y Change are new to the "scene" and your comments are hardly going to instil confidence in them. Anyway, although biased, I thought they were great and have a couple of really good tunes. I enjoyed Ashley Park as always YOTM were alright, didn't think much of the uber-effected vocals. Manatees were great but could have done with being a tad louder!