I don't really rate shredders unless they're doing something near-tasteful, but that's just me. My top guitarists would be: Jeff Buckley - totally organic, soulful style. Favourite guitarist. Omar Rodriguez-Lopez - with Jim Ward as well, I guess. Ian MacKaye/Guy Piccioto (Fugazi) Thurston Moore/Lee Ranaldo/Kim Gordon (Sonic Youth) - Kim is better on bass though. Kurt Ballou (Converge) Jimmy Page (Zep) - really the only "guitarist's guitarist" who I like. Lou Reed/Sterling Morrision (VU) - minimal and noisy, great stuff.