»

[HairyScaryMark]

Incase the Estrella singer reads this. I like his singing voice. Quite unique by what's going around at the moment.

[Tam o' Shantie]

Haha, this thread is fantastic. Pish, Spinal Tap wannabes. This band is a joke. Awful style, terrible playing, anyone who praises them for being 'brave' is clearly tripping, too. Not every band has low enough self esteem to find it a challenge to stay away from pawning fad music.

[Camie]

Originally Posted by Stephen

well the look they go for is hardly 'flavour of the week'

That maybe so but they are ripping off just about every 80's metal band. They don't even sound that tight, the guitar playing is too rigid and the whole song just drags at that pace to be honest.

But, like Milner said, there is much worse bands out there.

[bladeola]

Originally Posted by Camie

That maybe so but they are ripping off just about every 80's metal band. They don't even sound that tight, the guitar playing is too rigid and the whole song just drags at that pace to be honest.

But, like Milner said, there is much worse bands out there.

Not being a dick but I would guess you dont know THAT much about 80's metal. They're not ripping off every 80's metal band at all. They are heavily influenced by 70's and 80's hard rock.

[Old Gold]

I don't like that Estrella never follow these posts up.

If I'd requested feedback, I'd have at least thanked people for compliments, and I'd definately inquire further as to why some people thought I was straight up shit in an effort to improve. Just good manners in the first instance though.

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

I don't like that Estrella never follow these posts up.

If I'd requested feedback, I'd have at least thanked people for compliments, and I'd definately inquire further as to why some people thought I was straight up shit in an effort to improve. Just good manners in the first instance though.

Fair point, but the criticism has hardly been constructive has it?

[Cloud]

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

I don't like that Estrella never follow these posts up.

If I'd requested feedback, I'd have at least thanked people for compliments, and I'd definately inquire further as to why some people thought I was straight up shit in an effort to improve. Just good manners in the first instance though.

I doubt they're even posted by the band, hence the impersonal feel of the posts.

[Hog]

They seem to be good at their particular genre.

Metal? Estralla? Don't think so. Rawk n roll.

[Old Gold]

Originally Posted by Diesel

Fair point, but the criticism has hardly been constructive has it?

Well there you go. Watching people saying 'you're balls' isn't going to do them any good. They could be demmanding to know why they deserve such harsh criticism.

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

I don't like that Estrella never follow these posts up.

If I'd requested feedback, I'd have at least thanked people for compliments, and I'd definately inquire further as to why some people thought I was straight up shit in an effort to improve. Just good manners in the first instance though.

that's very true, if they had asked for feedback, they might want to follow it up.

but they didn't ask for feedback. they simply posted a link to the video and said 'feel free to leave any comments'.

so eat a dick.

(that band you've been listening to is called simply 'gallows' by the way, not 'the gallows')