»

[milner]

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

It's not brave pretending to be an 80s hair band when Aerosmith are still releasing and selling Greatest Hits cds.

The guitars are muddy, the drum sound is flabby, the playing is downright boring and the vocalist is pub band standard at best. It wouldn't matter if they were playing this naff bollocks or Girls Aloud covers. Pish.

wow you know that much about a bands sound from watching a crappy video, can you teach me that trick?
A question, how many famous bands have exceptional singers? Also how many famous bands have awful singers? I cant seem to find out where it said you had to be better than "pub" standard to make it in a band.

[milner]

Originally Posted by Cloud

Well, let's see. If this site is as important as it would like to be, then it's bound to be read by anyone looking for Estrella on the internet. Every topic recently posted by them has had loads of slagging of them, so you know, might not be the wisest idea to keep posting emotionless "press releases" on here.

But I just realised that I hadn't commented, soo...

Nothing wrong with the music, it does fit the style perfectly. But...what the hell is with the guy's voice? it's fucking terrible...

pish flaps almost every stayover thread had heaps of slagging us of, never stopped us as much as people would have liked. From expiereince the more people make fun on here the more people are interested.

[HairyScaryMark]

I quite enjoyed the music but the sound quality is bad, in the way it sounds distorted.

The video is quite well done, apart from the sound quality. Quite a good stage presence and such.

[HeinzHines]

Originally Posted by milner

I cant seem to find out where it said you had to be better than "pub" standard to make it in a band.

Surely the notion that you have 'made it' already means you are better than 'pub standard' because if you have 'made it' then surely you aren't playing in pubs, unless you have really low standards of what 'making it' is.

[milner]

Originally Posted by project:venhell

Surely the notion that you have 'made it' already means you are better than 'pub standard' because if you have 'made it' then surely you aren't playing in pubs, unless you have really low standards of what 'making it' is.

there are many singers in signed bands who are no better at singin than the estrella guy.

[Old Gold]

Originally Posted by milner

there are many singers in signed bands who are no better at singin than the estrella guy.

It doesn't mean I have to fucking rate them.

[milner]

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

It doesn't mean I have to fucking rate them.

i never fucking said you had to, i only pointed out the fucking fact

[Old Gold]

Originally Posted by milner

i never fucking said you had to, i only pointed out the fucking fact

So what's the point in the fact?

[milner]

Originally Posted by SpanishArmada

So what's the point in the fact?

i thought that was quite simple maybe it was the lay out of the sentence that confused you, here ill make it simpler;

Not every singer in every band is great at singing

[Old Gold]

I don't care what other bands are like ('famous' or otherwise). My feedback only apply to Estrella, and strictly that video. Sorry if you don't like it Milner, but my oppinion really has nothing to do with you.