iconAll times are GMT. The time now is 06:53. | Welcome to aberdeen-music! Please register for free in order to access all areas of the web site and to post on our forums.


» Forums » Other Forums » General Discussion » Movies & TV » America vs Britain

Movies & TV The forum for all movie and television related discussion.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 12-08-2009, 07:53   #1 (permalink)

 
The_Tank's Avatar

The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Kingswells
joined: Nov 2003
posts: 243
bands: Uncalm, Escape Today
talents: Drums

Default America vs Britain

When it comes to drama on television, who makes it better. In my opinion america just do it better, they have the budgets to make high quality shows, there writers are better and there shows just interest me more.

Even when i was growing up and we didn't have sky and watched shows like the bill, coronation street, heartbeat. I hated watching those shows, they were just not for me.

In saying that we make amazing gameshows, bring back crystal maze.

Discuss.
The_Tank is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 12-08-2009, 08:25   #2 (permalink)

 
Alkaline's Avatar

Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.
Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Aberdeen
joined: Aug 2003
posts: 7,277
bands: Genevieve, Amaeru
talents: Vocals/Guitar/Bass

Send a message via MSN to Alkaline
Default

Hmmm,

Ultraviolet
This Life
Killer Net
Hustle
Queer as Folk
Red Riding
Teachers
Sugar Rush
Messiah
Bergerac
Spooks
The Buddha of Suburbia
The Crow Road
Life on Mars
Ashes to Ashes
Our Friends in the North
Cracker
Prime Suspect
Rome
Silent Witness
Survivors (70s and recent versions)
The Street
Taggart (early stuff only)
Waking The Dead
Apparitions

That's almost exclusively ignoring British comedy. I admit not everything in that list is to everyone's taste but there is some great drama in there. I'm sure i'll remember more.
Alkaline is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 08:47   #3 (permalink)

 
John W's Avatar

John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.John W is a community guru with 386 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: City Centre
joined: Sep 2007
posts: 1,776
bands: Saikano

Send a message via MSN to John W
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alkaline View Post
Hmmm,

Ultraviolet
This Life
Killer Net
Hustle
Queer as Folk
Red Riding
Teachers
Sugar Rush
Messiah
Bergerac
Spooks
The Buddha of Suburbia
The Crow Road
Life on Mars
Ashes to Ashes
Our Friends in the North
Cracker
Prime Suspect
Rome
Silent Witness
Survivors (70s and recent versions)
The Street
Taggart (early stuff only)
Waking The Dead
Apparitions

That's almost exclusively ignoring British comedy. I admit not everything in that list is to everyone's taste but there is some great drama in there. I'm sure i'll remember more.
There's only a small amount in there i've heard of/seen, the ones in bold though we're really good when i watched them.

I love the American Sci-Fi/Dramas, Heroes and Lost are my favourite TV shows
__________________
John W is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 08:56   #4 (permalink)

 
The_Tank's Avatar

The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Kingswells
joined: Nov 2003
posts: 243
bands: Uncalm, Escape Today
talents: Drums

Default

Never seen any of these shows, maybe hustle. The old school itv has rotted my british viewing.
The_Tank is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 09:00   #5 (permalink)

 
Alkaline's Avatar

Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.
Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Aberdeen
joined: Aug 2003
posts: 7,277
bands: Genevieve, Amaeru
talents: Vocals/Guitar/Bass

Send a message via MSN to Alkaline
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Tank View Post
Never seen any of these shows, maybe hustle. The old school itv has rotted my british viewing.
See, the Bill, Coronation Street and Heartbeat are all family serials or soaps. There is some boundary pushing, quality, British drama on TV. You might need to watch some to see it though.

It's no secret that the Americans are always trying to import our TV series (Life On Mars, The Office etc) over to their market yet we very rarely do the same with theirs.

Don't get me wrong, there are some brilliant US television programs out there but there are also some quality British ones as well.
Alkaline is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 09:09   #6 (permalink)

 
The_Tank's Avatar

The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.The_Tank is well respected with 54 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Kingswells
joined: Nov 2003
posts: 243
bands: Uncalm, Escape Today
talents: Drums

Default

I never thought of it like that, probably because the televison isn't controlled by me in my house and it seems like it goes from one crappy soap to the other, untill house and lie to me appear on sky one.

Also seen taggart, not a fan.
The_Tank is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 09:14   #7 (permalink)

 
Godzilla Blues's Avatar

Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.Godzilla Blues is a splendid one to behold with 558 reputation points.

Profile
Male
joined: Aug 2008
posts: 847

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alkaline View Post
Hmmm,

Ultraviolet
This Life
Killer Net
Hustle
Queer as Folk
Red Riding
Teachers
Sugar Rush
Messiah
Bergerac
Spooks
The Buddha of Suburbia
The Crow Road
Life on Mars
Ashes to Ashes
Our Friends in the North
Cracker
Prime Suspect
Rome
Silent Witness
Survivors (70s and recent versions)
The Street
Taggart (early stuff only)
Waking The Dead
Apparitions

That's almost exclusively ignoring British comedy. I admit not everything in that list is to everyone's taste but there is some great drama in there. I'm sure i'll remember more.
Huge omission - The Lakes!!! Best British TV ever if you ask me. Even if series 2 was completely mad.

Shameless should also be included, certainly at least the first 3 series.

I thought Teachers went down hill after series 2.

haven't seen much of that list since I don't tend to watch TV, I usually end up buying whole series on DVD if I fancy it.
Godzilla Blues is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 10:17   #8 (permalink)

 
Le Stu's Avatar

Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.Le Stu is a splendid one to behold with 767 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Northern internerts
joined: Oct 2007
posts: 1,585
talents: I shake it ina jar

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Tank View Post
When it comes to drama on television, who makes it better. In my opinion america just do it better, they have the budgets to make high quality shows, there writers are better and there shows just interest me more.

Even when i was growing up and we didn't have sky and watched shows like the bill, coronation street, heartbeat. I hated watching those shows, they were just not for me.

In saying that we make amazing gameshows, bring back crystal maze.

Discuss.
I remember growing up in the 80s when all the drama was British and the American shows were mostly soaps and action series. That's changed a lot, especially since our obsession with reality TV and talent shows gained in the last decade. We seem to be exporting that trend to the US and importing their scripted TV shows more than anything else these days.

Too many period dramas too. Fuck that...
Le Stu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 10:53   #9 (permalink)

 
Alkaline's Avatar

Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.
Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.Alkaline has much to be proud of with 1094 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: Aberdeen
joined: Aug 2003
posts: 7,277
bands: Genevieve, Amaeru
talents: Vocals/Guitar/Bass

Send a message via MSN to Alkaline
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Godzilla Blues View Post
Huge omission - The Lakes!!! Best British TV ever if you ask me. Even if series 2 was completely mad.

Shameless should also be included, certainly at least the first 3 series.

I thought Teachers went down hill after series 2.

haven't seen much of that list since I don't tend to watch TV, I usually end up buying whole series on DVD if I fancy it.
Ahhh, the Lakes was fantastic. Almost like a UK Twin Peaks in places.
Alkaline is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 11:06   #10 (permalink)

 
delboy's Avatar

delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.delboy is a community guru with 268 reputation points.

Profile
Male
location: east anglia
joined: Aug 2003
posts: 3,952
bands: The Helium Legg
talents: synths, drum machines, computers, tapes, radios

Send a message via MSN to delboy
Default

i'd go for british drama and comedy over american, some great stuff has come out the states but i much prefer british stuff, mainly bbc stuff - ITV dramas can be incredibly poor, i think they try too hard to emulate the beeb at times. having said that ITV are capable of some good stuff such as the bill (though havent watched it ages) and a touch of frost. hell even midsomer murders can be quite gripping. but then again some of the dross ITV produce is shocking, anyone remember rosemary and thyme - 2 crime busting gardeners???? beyond shit.
delboy is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Gallows - Grey Britain The59Sound Music Discussion 13 13-05-2009 02:21
Little Britain Fans only EchelonDivision General Discussion 5 20-05-2006 16:43
Only In Britain! Bux General Discussion 57 25-04-2006 20:55
Burning Britain - a history of UK punk 1980-1984 allsystemsfail Music Discussion 5 11-07-2004 18:51
Salako & Former Miss America.....sun 6th June Dizzy Storm Dizzy Storm 2 31-05-2004 20:07