aberdeen-music

Want your banner here?   Don't want to see these?


Movies & TV The forum for all movie and television related discussion.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old
  (#1 (permalink))

Diesel's Avatar


Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Dec 2005
bands: HeadRush
talents: Guitar, Vocals
location: Fintray
Default Control - Anyone else seen this movie yet? - 14-02-2008, 11:16

Apologies if this has already been discussed, but I couldn't find another thread about this movie.

I watched "Control" - about the life and death of Joy Division's Ian Curtis - on the plane to Joburg earlier in the week.

Anyone else seen it?

Opinions?

Well acted and sometimes moving, but a film that can make *Schindler's List, Eraserhead and PI appear cheerful and uplifting in comparison has some serious problems.

There's some dark humour - mostly added by Tony Kebbell who played their cocky and foul-mouth manager Rob Gretton - but mostly it's doom & gloom.

Ironic that Curtis should name his band Joy Division when there seems to have been very little, if any, joy in his own life.

*I mention these three movies as they were also shot in B&W and were hard work!
   
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links


Old
  (#2 (permalink))

huntedbyafreak's Avatar


huntedbyafreak is on a distinguished road with 5 influence and 22 reputation points.huntedbyafreak is on a distinguished road with 5 influence and 22 reputation points.huntedbyafreak is on a distinguished road with 5 influence and 22 reputation points.

Profile
status: Offline
joined: Aug 2003
talents: Fear and Surprise and Joy
location: Aberdeen
Default 14-02-2008, 11:23

Quote:
Originally Posted by Diesel View Post
Ironic that Curtis should name his band Joy Division when there seems to have been very little, if any, joy in his own life.
Joy Division is named for the systematic rape/prositution of Jewish women by the Nazis. The Nazis would go to the 'Joy Division' for kicks.

Not a dig but failing to see the irony...
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#3 (permalink))

Diesel's Avatar


Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.Diesel is well respected with 5 influence and 60 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Dec 2005
bands: HeadRush
talents: Guitar, Vocals
location: Fintray
Default 14-02-2008, 11:37

Quote:
Originally Posted by huntedbyafreak View Post
Joy Division is named for the systematic rape/prositution of Jewish women by the Nazis. The Nazis would go to the 'Joy Division' for kicks.

Not a dig but failing to see the irony...
I'm well aware of the origins of the name - the simple irony is that an apparently joyless man, played in a band with "Joy" in the title. Just an observation on my part, nothing deeper.
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#4 (permalink))

Sue Denim..'s Avatar


Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Apr 2004
bands: The local band of drunken pub singers.
talents: Mandolin & Drumkit (Badly)
location: Moorings Bar
Default 17-02-2008, 14:32

When I saw the poster for this film I thought the guy looked like Pete Dougherty therefore I drew my own conclusions and thought.... I'm not giving a fucking penny to that cunt.

... and I got it wrong..... again.
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#5 (permalink))

Sam L4's Avatar


Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.Sam L4 is an honor to be around with 8 influence and 129 reputation points.
5 Highscores

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Feb 2005
bands: 45 A-Side Records
talents: Guitar, Bass
location: ABDN/GLASGOW
Default 17-02-2008, 15:35

Yeah i liked it.


45 A-Side Records Debut Release - FFAR001 - Out Now! (Get it in One Up)

"..the best compilation of Scottish talent to be collected recently - the sort of thing the word ’seminal’ was coined for." - Is This Music?

   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#6 (permalink))

Jan Deal's Avatar


Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.Jan Deal is an ambassador of goodwill with 10 influence and 91 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: May 2004
bands: Panda Eyes; 1864 in Art
talents: Mainstream musical theatre
location: Starfield Road
Default 26-02-2008, 12:48

Is there a surprise twist ending by any chance?
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#7 (permalink))

Alkaline's Avatar


Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.Alkaline is an honor to be around with 11 influence and 108 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Aug 2003
bands: Genevieve
talents: Vocals/Guitar/Bass
location: Aberdeen
Default 26-02-2008, 19:20

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan Deal View Post
Is there a surprise twist ending by any chance?
No, i've heard they leave you hanging....
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#8 (permalink))

Dave's Avatar


Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Jun 2004
talents: I am at two with nature
location: Aberdeen
Default 03-03-2008, 20:36

I watched it at the weekend. It's a little bit slow-moving in places, and the character development could have been handled better, but the atmosphere and tension are spot-on. And of course, the music's brilliant.


   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#9 (permalink))

Larsen B's Avatar


Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.Larsen B is an ambassador of goodwill with 9 influence and 98 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Mar 2004
location: Westhill
Default 04-03-2008, 20:50

It's main strength is painting Curtis a genuine troubled young man as opposed to some tortured genius and icon. The scene where Deborah has him cornered in the bedroom and he just shrinks was particularly well done. I got it for my birthday but haven't re-watched it yet.
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#10 (permalink))

bluesxman's Avatar


bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.bluesxman is an ambassador of goodwill with 8 influence and 87 reputation points.

Profile
gender: Male
status: Offline
joined: Apr 2005
bands: 1864 in Art
Default 10-04-2008, 07:25

Watched it last night, it was pretty decent, the guy did look a bit too much like Pete Doherty a lot of the time though.

Toby Kebbel was superb as Rob Gretton, and he had the best line of the film when the guy they got to sing in place of Curtis asked for his 20 quid and he retorted, ‘It’s here in my fuck off pocket’.

The complete viewing experience was completely ruined however by the inclusion of a dreadful Killer’s cover of Shadowplay over the end credits, why oh why was that necessary?
   
Reply With Quote
Reply



Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
superhero movie news! Mr.Mike General Discussion 12 04-08-2006 10:45
Torque - Worst. Movie. Ever. Diesel General Discussion 30 26-05-2006 10:58
Simpsons Movie Larsen B General Discussion 18 05-04-2006 16:21
Yamaha ProMix01 Digital mixer Compuphonic Equipment 0 25-10-2005 00:03
Dukes of Hazzard Movie Trailer New Found Power General Discussion 7 09-05-2005 08:24


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:44.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.10
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.1.0
All web site content ©2001 - 2008, aberdeen-music