»

If a woman is laying into you with punches and kicks(when you havent layed a finger on her) and during one of these punches you grab her wrist and twist it until it breaks(accidentally) do you think this is acceptable?

[JaseyBoi]

no mate no voilence towards the oposite sex is tolerable..If it happens walk away dont go grabbing pushing laying ontop of (in a non sexual way of course) ...This is what i was brought up to believe......

Can i just say that the wrist bone is not paper thin and a slight grab would not break it a firm grip and twist would..

Is this a friend of a friend this happened to mate... or was it you and the post is threw guilt?

accident or no accident dont retaliate just walk away as at the end of the day it dont matter if she battered u sensless broke both your legs and your arms people will only remember that u broke hers not that she crippled you!..

[Bass Cadet]

Well speaking as a girl, I think the kiniving/lying/emotional trauma you blokes inflict hurts far worse than anything you could do physically. I'd rather take the slap - it heals quicker. But thats just my opinion - I know everyone will disagree with me!

Sorry, but twist it until it accidentally breaks?

Unless she has brittle bones, then the person twisting her wrist has obviously been applying a fair amount of force.

I counld understand if you twisted it untle it got sprained by accident, but til it breaks?!?!

[beeker]

every accident is caused.

[You Nazi]

girls get away with far too much. I wouldn't say breaking her wrist would be a good thing to do but she would deserve a fair slap back.

Originally Posted by Bass Cadet

Well speaking as a girl, I think the kiniving/lying/emotional trauma you blokes inflict hurts far worse than anything you could do physically. I'd rather take the slap - it heals quicker. But thats just my opinion - I know everyone will disagree with me!

[David]

i see no problem with what happened there

yes you shouldnt touch a girl and all that, and i would never try to hurt someone or start any fights, but if you get attacked you deserve a right to defend yourself, whatever sex, generally ending up breaking someones wrist is extreme whatever the circumstances, and it would be preferrable to find some other way out, but that goes for either sex. the act of defending yourself is perfectly fine to me, it seems bloody stupid to just take a beating and not try to defend yourself

equal rights and all that, handy when some female wants a job, but its still completely unacceptable to defend youself if attacked by a female? bullshit

its bloody stupid that there is a notion that a female can attack someone physically and get off with it, purely because they are female

David

[calum]

You should go and tell someone. Preferably a parent or a teacher.

[Afro Droid]

Originally Posted by Bass Cadet

Well speaking as a girl, I think the kiniving/lying/emotional trauma you blokes inflict hurts far worse than anything you could do physically.

I could list at least 20 male mates who would say the same of women. Me included. But that's the battle of the sexes innit? Can't live with them, can't cut their heads off and bury them in the back garden.

It's easy for a bloke to pacify a girl without breaking any bones...