»

[droid]

Originally Posted by droid

Here is a POSITIVE comment,bounce mps your mixes down to 96kbps for myspace.Myspace will convert files to this and sometimes this will make your choons sound pants!

pretty constructive to me....

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Sorry, what?

I have at no point questioned the constructivity of your feedback.

Constructivity may not be a word.

[droid]

Exactly...all you want to do is argue.All i did was try to HELP the guy.

[ca_gere]

I think it was the 'un-listenable' part that ruined the diplomatics. If ever there's a word you don't want to see in a review it's that.

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Originally Posted by droid

Exactly...all you want to do is argue.All i did was try to HELP the guy.

No, I don't want to argue, I want to call you on getting on a guy's back who only did what the OP was asking for.

I'd also probably feel a bit less rage if you used the spacebar after fullstops.

On a side-note, and back on topic I've not listened to the music yet, but will try and give it a listen tonight so that I can rip it to pieces and leave the OP feeling 'totally destroyed'.

[KimyReizeger]

Originally Posted by ca_gere

I think it was the 'un-listenable' part that ruined the diplomatics. .

I just meant that because of the number of 'things' happening in several of the tracks - particularly those of the whooshing, sweeping, abrasive sort - and taking into account the reduction in audio quality inherent to myspace, that I found it a painful listen.

[Alkaline]

I'm sure it's just the myspace mix that is the cause but it all sound very harsh to my ears. The tunes are a difficult listen as a result and a lot of it sounds like the sort of stuff you could do with that music mix thing you used to get for the original playstation. Who knows, maybe with a better mix and some of the edges smoothed over it might lose what you were going for though. Hard call. I was sure i'd like it though, it ticks a lot of boxes on the face of it, and i like a lot of your influences.

I liked smsd2 best out of the lot of them, it sounded the most together and i liked the progression of the track.

[RockAustin]

Some lively chat going on here. Feedback is never a bad thing, and you certainly need to have a thick skin when you make music, whatever it is.

Keep the songs coming, looking forward to hearing how protools changes your sound.

[Suimasen]

Bloody hell there has been alot going on since i last looked at this. Not sure where to start!

Right first off, i think that kimy's comment's where not too harsh and fairly reasonable though i did find the second one slightly friendlier (not sure if that's the right word to use but hopefully you know what i mean) than the first one. I also see droid's idea of trying to encourage people with their writing abit more because sometimes i do think folk on this can be abit too insensitive to other indivduals work.
Alkaline i hope with better mixing that you will like the tracks haha.
I do very much appreciate the support from RockAustin, idle wild, ca_gere and aekido!
At the end of the day, i would of actually been amazed if i had put these tracks up and not had any sort of form of negative feedback!
In my defence to this, i'm still new to this format of writing and that it is my first attempt at it.

[Suimasen]

Originally Posted by Adam Easy Wishes

On a side-note, and back on topic I've not listened to the music yet, but will try and give it a listen tonight so that I can rip it to pieces and leave the OP feeling 'totally destroyed'.

i like it. haha