»

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Originally Posted by droid

Absolutely,but just because you get "spurned on" by negative criticism,surely doesn't justify you doing that to another artist.After all who are you,to judge them or their music.

He is a member of the website the OP posted on in the 'feedback forum'.

I believe he is entitled to give any feedback he wants.

[droid]

Originally Posted by Adam Easy Wishes

He is a member of the website the OP posted on in the 'feedback forum'.

I believe he is entitled to give any feedback he wants.

Easy tiger,I didn't say he wasn't entitled to do that did i?

[Adam Easy Wishes]

You asked who he was to judge someone's music. The guy whose music it is posted it up here to be judged.

[droid]

Originally Posted by Adam Easy Wishes

You asked who he was to judge someone's music. The guy whose music it is posted it up here to be judged.

Yes....feedback is different from judgement,negative comments can be counter productive.Why not say something positive rather than negative.There is a lot to be said for etiquette.I'm not here to argue with you!

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Originally Posted by http://www.thefreedictionary.com/judgement

3. judgement

judgement - the cognitive process of reaching a decision or drawing conclusions

Listen, judge (as per above), give feedback.

If all anyone did was pick out the good things, he'd think there was nothing to work at.

[ca_gere]

If everyone only ever said nice things, we'd never get anywhere in life. He was maybe a bit harsh but that's all part and parcel of putting your music up for scrutiny. Like Kimyreizeger said, negativity can be productive. In the same sense positivity can be counter productive ('everyone tells me that's an ace tune therefore im not gonna try harder to perfect it')

Whatever, back to discussing the music.

[ca_gere]

Originally Posted by Adam Easy Wishes

If all anyone did was pick out the good things, he'd think there was nothing to work at.

*Same thought high five*

[droid]

Haha,Erm you don't have to tell me what judge means.Again that's not what i said, constructive criticism is far more FRIENDLY wouldn't you say.Then you can go back and work on those points and not feel totally destroyed.

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Originally Posted by ca_gere

*Same thought high five*

[Adam Easy Wishes]

Originally Posted by droid

Haha,Erm you don't have to tell me what judge means.Again that's not what i said, constructive criticism is far more FRIENDLY wouldn't you say.Then you can go back and work on those points and not feel totally destroyed.

Originally Posted by KimyReizeger

I think:

The beats are pretty generic and it's way too busy. A lot of the songs seem to be, rather than one or two really good ideas; many ok-ish ones. I often think DAWs give you too much choice. A bit of character in the sounds and depth perspective in the production would be nice. Given poor myspace quality, I find it almost un-listenable.

But there are also some pretty cool ideas, and the beginnings of both the second and third songs are unusual and quite gripping.

That seems pretty constructive to me.

Mentioned what he disliked, what he'd like to see and then what he liked.