I think that if you posted material that you were requesting feedback for in the music discussion forum it would quickly become a "second pager" and therefore achieve nothing, which in all honesty is not much less than it's achieving at the moment.
(I had a quick look, music discussion first page goes back 4 days,feedback forum first page goes back a month)
I think the problem with the feedback forum is that to give feedback on a song the listener has to both have strong views on it and the ability to put these views into words other than "I like that" or "that's shit" because most people, quite rightly, don't regard these as constructive.
Perhaps an anonymous, one time per user rating system would get better (certainly more) results than expecting people to explain WHY they like/hate something.
|